Why the Strongest Engineers Are Never in Your Applicant Pool
- makenatechsolution
- 5 hours ago
- 2 min read
Your engineering position just received 247 applicants.
Congratulations — you may have just created a bigger hiring problem.
The Volume Myth
One of the biggest misconceptions in hiring is that more applicants equals a better talent pool. In reality, it often just means more noise.
We've watched engineering managers spend hours reviewing resumes, only to discover:
Candidates who don't have the required technical expertise
Applicants who need sponsorship for roles that require U.S. work authorization
Professionals applying from across the country for positions that require relocation they aren't willing to make
Job seekers using AI to tailor resumes that appear to be a match on paper — but don't hold up in an interview
Where Your Best Candidates Actually Are
Meanwhile, the strongest candidates often never apply at all.
They're busy leading projects, solving complex problems, and delivering results for their current employer. They aren't spending their evenings refreshing job boards.
This is where many hiring teams unintentionally lose valuable time — not from a shortage of resumes, but from a flood of the wrong ones.
A Better Approach: Precision Over Volume
Instead of reviewing hundreds of resumes, imagine starting with three to five highly qualified professionals who have already been vetted for:
✔ Technical capability✔ Industry experience✔ Career motivations✔ Compensation alignment✔ Availability
Hiring isn't about finding the most applicants. It's about finding the right applicants.
The best engineering searches don't begin with volume. They begin with precision.
The Question Every Hiring Leader Should Ask
Would you rather review 247 resumes — or interview three candidates you could confidently hire?
If your engineering team is drowning in applicants but still struggling to find the right fit, let's talk about a more targeted approach to your next search.
By Jodi Barcelona
Makena Tech Solutions
Jodi Barcelona is the CEO, Managing Director of Makena Tech Solutions, a WBENC-certified staffing and recruiting firm specializing in engineering, technology, finance, and executive search. With more than 27 years of leadership experience in human resources, talent acquisition, and workforce strategy, she helps organizations solve complex hiring challenges and connect with exceptional talent.
Comments